The Raiders should not take McFadden

15. March 2008

I've seen more than a couple of mock drafts that predict the Raiders will take McFadden with the #4 pick. The logic is entirely based on the assumption that Davis still thinks it is 1977 instead of 2007 (I'll concede all points regarding the sweatsuits and hairdo) and that you should always draft speed regardless of whether they fit into your system. This of course ignores many years of Davis drafts.

The Raiders currently have four backs on their roster all of which could probably start or share starting time for most NFL teams (Vargas, Jordan, Rhodes, Bush). IMO, drafting McFadden, beyond his extensive off the field issues, would be a galactic mistake.

The Raiders just lost Sapp. They desperately need linemen both offensive and defensive. If Dorsey is not available, then they should take Sedric Ellis.  Forget all of the USC relations and such, Ellis is the first or second best defensive lineman in the draft. I can see arguments for trading down, but if they cannot and Dorsey is taken, then Ellis is the right fit.

  

Football

blog comments powered by Disqus